Showing posts with label Kristin Scott Thomas. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Kristin Scott Thomas. Show all posts

Monday, 23 February 2009

I've Loved You So Long - Il y a longtemps que Je t'aime (2008)


Three 2008 films in a row. Unbelievable. So what did I make of this, a lyrical French film about Juliette (a marvelous Kristin Scott Thomas), returning to live with her sister Lea having been released from prison 15 years after murdering her son? Beloved by critics, including my colleague, though not by Oscar, this didn't quite manage to inspire me as it has others, despite good performances from the leads.

There is no doubt that this is Scott Thomas' film and my colleague is right to feel indignant at the lack of nomination, though, sadly, this is what I've come to expect from the Academy. That said, Elsa Zylberstein, who plays the sister, delivers a more understated, though no less compelling performance. There are some interesting male efforts here too, particularly from Laurent Grevill, as Michel. But this is a feminine film, drawing on tender, emotional, themes of sisterhood, belonging and togetherness and it is right that the two leads dominate proceedings.

A slow- burning film, this still never fails to engage it's audience, largely down to the sublime performances. Juliette is a very human character, invested with huge emotional and psychological depth by an excellent script. This is a complex character, but Scott Thomas is more than up to the task. Although you can catch her English accent in places, this is nicely, and very plausibly, explained away and that can, besides, hardly be a criticism coming from someone with as dodgy French as mine. And Lea is an equally deep character, with just as much of a history and with just as many issues, though they are naturally different and perhaps not as insurmountable. In short, this feels a truly human drama, full of human life, struggle, beauty and redemption, many of the themes that are present in films of the highest order.

I would, however, urge caution about putting this in the very top rung of cinematic achievement. It's good, and I enjoyed it, but, ultimately, it failed to inspire me that it was a work of genuine greatness. There are a few reasons for this. Firstly, what is an incredible, show-stopping, last scene (for the brilliant emotion-fueled exchange between the two sisters) is dulled by a shocking piece of editing leading up to it, which can be put down to little more than laziness. Unfortunately, for me at least, it had a negative effect. Secondly, as good as Scott Thomas is, I couldn't fully believe the historical actions of her character as explained in the final reel, which left another slightly bitter taste. And thirdly and finally, I couldn't help but feel that the bravery of the film-makers ebbed away slightly towards the end and they didn't quite have the bottle to make a fully empathetic film about characters who do bad, even unforgivable, things. This remains generally uncharted territory, the latest final taboo, for film-making. It will be a spectacular, epoch-defining, film that crosses those boundaries, but this isn't it.

Perhaps I shouldn't criticise this for being something it isn't and should just have enjoyed it for what it is. But I genuinely think I did. And, ultimately, my enjoyment was spoilt by the fact that this, good as it is, didn't quite deliver on all its promises.

B

Wednesday, 21 January 2009

Oscar nominations tomorrow

So I've looked into my crystal ball and it tells me the following shall be nominated for Best Picture...

Slumdog Millionaire
Frost/Nixon

Milk

The Curious Case of Benjamin Button

and, controversially, Wall*E

Everyone else is saying The Dark Knight for that last slot. I have two problems with that. One: it's a comic book film, and however well received it was, comic book films don't get nominations. And two: it wasn't that good. I think a lone directing nom for Nolan is as likely as a best picture nom for the film, but of course I'm not exactly going to be surprised if the Bat does sneak in. I personally would like to see The Wrestler (almost certainly my film of 08 - review imminent) make it but alas it seems Mickey Rourke will be flying the flag on his own.

The other nom I am looking out for is Kristin Scott Thomas for Best Actress. Never did I think it would be possible for her to miss out but it seems that it might be. The favoured five seem to be...

Winslet, Streep, Hathaway, Leo and Jolie.

I cannot believe it, but KST may miss out yet again. A real shame.

All will be revealed at insane o-clock Pacific time in the States (around 1pm in the UK I think.)

Monday, 10 November 2008

Easy Virtue

This thoroughly appalling British film marks the 6th occasion this year that I have bailed on a film before the credits rolled. One leading American critic got into trouble a few weeks ago after it emerged he reviewed a film he'd only seen the first 8 minutes of. I stayed for significantly more than that, although I don't think I quite made it to the hour mark. Perhaps one shouldn't review a film unless they've seen all of it, or perhaps if you do you should be upfront about it. Well here's me being upfront: if you don't think I should review a movie I didn't see to its conclusion, treat this as a review of the first 45 minutes.

It is very possible that Easy Virtue defied all expectation and suddenly found some shred of competence in a screenplay that had thus far adapted a Noel Coward play so badly that it made the playwright seem positively humourless.

It is possible that every single attempt at humour suddenly hit the mark where they had hitherto missed so badly that is was excruciating to watch.

It is also possible that the makers of this thing realised that watching interiors shot as though they have been illuminated by candle-light was unacceptable and that they drafted in a proper cinematographer for the second half.

It is quite possible that the powers that be realised that a period film with a jazzed up soundtrack featuring covers of songs written decades after the film was set, Rose Royce's Car Wash being one example, was completely inappropriate and did nothing more than convey a hopelessly desperate attempt to appear whimsical, funky and cool.

It is certainly possible that Kristen Scott Thomas was given a character of substance in the second half rather than a two-dimensional pale imitation of her Gosford Park character.

It is possible that Biel and Barnes discovered some sort of screen chemistry that had eluded them.

It is possible that the actresses playing the two sisters were recast with actors with more charisma.

It is definitely possible that the director (Stephan Elliot) realised that you don't have to invent new camera angles or movements to make your mark on the industry. Turning the camera 90 degrees to shoot a car sideways on is not clever. It's just irritating.

Yes, all this is possible.

Is it likely? No.

D

Monday, 29 September 2008

I've Loved You So Long

Believe the hype. Kristin Scott Thomas will be back in the Oscar mix after what seems an interminable wait. She may even win. She certainly deserves to.

Her performance in Philippe Claudel's gripping film is one you take notice of immediately. Within 5 minutes you know you are watching something special. By the end of a film in which you've spent nearly every frame with her enigmatic, captivating character you'll be ready to hand her an Oscar.

I've Loved You So Long opens with the a lingering shot of a raw, uncomfortable Juliette (Scott Thomas). She sits alone in a waiting room clinging to a cigarette - her make-up-less face blank and emotionless. The appearance of her sister Lea (Elsa Zylberstein), whom she hasn't seen for 15 years, yields the merest hint of emotion, and you sense 99% of that hint takes the greatest of efforts. When introduced to Lea's family, Juliette cannot help but put up a defensive, withdrawn exterior. Painfully uncomfortable in just about any social setting she withdraws into herself even further. Adjusting to her new life lodging with her sister's family, it is only with Lea's mute father-in-law that she can feel totally at ease.

It is difficult to say too much more about I've Loved You So Long without giving away details about character and plot. Going in with too much knowledge would harm a screenplay that is carefully constructed to reveal information gradually and carefully, but if this makes the film sound overly self-conscious it is anything but. It is actually a rather simple, contemporary character driven piece of the kind the French do so well.

A story about one woman and her inner demons can only work if that woman is relentlessly fascinating. As each layer of her Juliette is carefully removed, we get closer and closer to the real Juliette - the one hiding behind her masked countenance. And as we understand more and more about Juliette, we understand more and more about the truth behind the last fifteen years of her life. Each minor revelation drives the story forward towards a simultaneously uplifting and heart-wrenching climax.

Scott Thomas is an exceptionally gifted actress who has flirted with awards bodies all too infrequently in her career. Too often found in small, supporting roles, she has nevertheless come to attention of this site on 3 occasions. First coming to prominence in Four Weddings and a Funeral, she was perfect as the archetypal Brit with the stiff upper lip; a woman who suffers in silence with her unrequited love for a guy whose attentions will always be elsewhere. Her second performance of note found her in the attentions of the entire film industry - in The English Patient Thomas played opposite Ralph Fiennes and they engaged in a passionate, unbridled affair. She again found favour as the refined Brit but one this time whose passion was requited, although their love affair soon plagues her with the guilt of infidelity.

Many would point to The English Patient as a career highlight but for me she delivered her finest turn in Robert Altman's exceptional Gosford Park. Once more it was a small but perfectly formed role, and once again she plays someone in the upper classes, but she imbues her performance with enough nuance to avoid typecast: desperation and despair, wit and mischief. The only negative was that she wasn't on screen for long enough.

How refreshing then to see her dominate a film's running time. I've Loved You So Long is a film that is totally transfixed by Juliette, despite her having none of the usual trappings of a lead character. Juliette is clearly both beautiful and intelligent, but conveys instead a dowdy, fragile facade. Ably supported by Elsa Zylberstein, who may also receive awards notice, Scott Thomas really has landed the role of her career.

Claudel's screenplay might accurately be described as sparse, but that may convey the wrong message for this is an extremely accomplished film - the economical writing is one of the film's strengths. All of the film's characters, especially Juliette, say so much with so little dialogue. Scenes are no longer than necessary - there is no extraneous detail. Everything is focused on character development and the unfolding of a mystery that will have you completely absorbed from start to finish.

This is quite simply the film of the year. If I see a better one before the curtain comes down on 2008 then I am in for a real treat. If this movie and its star are not smothered with awards glory when the time comes to honour the films of the past 12 months then it would be nothing less than a travesty. Go see it. Right now.

A

Tuesday, 23 September 2008

Insane Friday

Five - count them, FIVE! - films released this weekend that I actually would like to see. They are...

Appaloosa - Ed Harris' western opened in the States to mixed reviews, but it has lots of positive things going for it including Ed Harris, and Viggo Mortensen (last years movieyears winner for me.)

Redbelt - a new David Mamet film starring a whole host of decent actors. Mamet's films are characterised by ensemble casts and snappy dialogue, and this looks no different. If it can match the unheralded near brilliance of something like Spartan (which no one saw but was great anyway) then it'll be well worth spending 2 hours with.

Righteous Kill - which I kinda know will be pretty rubbish but it stars Pacino and De Niro so you have to watch it anyway, not that either have done anything worth watching for years...

Taken - a child kidnapping thriller distinguished by an excellent trailer in which Liam Neeson speaks to his daughter's captors for practically the whole running time. The director's last feature (District B13) was very very good, Neeson looks on great form in the trailers and everything about this looks pretty slick. It might be just as dumb as 90% of other thrillers but something tells me this'll be highly enjoyable.

and a film that has come from off the radar to one of my most anticipated of the year...

I Loved You So Long - a French drama that has landed to rave reviews for the film itself, but particularly for star Kristin Scott Thomas who just happens to be one of the best actresses around. 3 movieyears nominations from me for Four Weddings..., The English Patient and Gosford Park - is another on the horizon? She was wonderful in a small role in last year's French smash Tell No One. I am eagerly awaiting this one.